The future of American Idol Season 18 remains in doubt, with production suspended due to coronavirus concerns.
But voting has already begun, because for the first time in the series’ history, viewers have been tasked with choosing between two “Final Judgment” contestants.
On last night’s part two Final Judgment episode – which was shot at the Hawaiian resort Aulani during happier, pre-pandemic times, on January 31st – it was revealed which of the remaining finalists would be rounding out this season’s top 20. However, it was a top 21 instead.
It all came down to rival retro country girls Lauren Mascitti and Grace Leer, and the judges were deadlocked.
“Your performances last night, both of them were really great,” said judge Luke Bryan. “Lauren, you showed us this rocking side we haven’t seen, and Grace, you were really one of the winners of the night, in my opinion. We have one position left, and we couldn’t make a decision. …So, you guys aren’t out of the woods. We’re going turn it over to America.” Ryan Seacrest then revealed that public voting would open immediately following last night’s episode, based on the ladies’ Hawaii showcase performances.
Idol returns over the next two Sundays with consecutive American Idol: This Is Me specials, with behind-the-scenes, biographical footage of the top contestants. Next Sunday, we’ll know whether Mascitti or Leer is in the finalized top 20. This year’s top 21:
- Faith Becnel
- Franklin Boone
- DeWayne Crocker, Jr.
- Cyniah Elise
- Kimmy Gabriela
- Julia Gargano
- Arthur Gunn
- Dillon James
- Aliana Jester
- Just Sam
- Louis Knight
- Grace Leer
- Francisco Martin
- Lauren Mascitti
- Nick Merico
- Makayla Phillips
- Lauren Spencer-Smith
- Sophia Wackerman
- Jovin Webb
- Jonny West
- Olivia Ximines